Skip To Main Content

Logo Image

Union Catholic High School Logo
Union Catholic High School
Scotch Plains, New Jersey
908-889-1600

Embracing AI in the Classroom: Enhancing Critical Thinking, Problem-Solving, and Creativity

By Dr. Marla James

As we embark on a new school year, integrating artificial intelligence (AI) into our educational practices presents exciting opportunities and unique challenges. In an AI-integrated world, our students must learn to use AI ethically and as an assistant rather than as a means of critical thinking. Used appropriately, AI can be a powerful ally in aiding problem-solving, creativity, and project-based learning among our students.

Understanding the Role of AI in Education

When used appropriately, AI tools can significantly improve student engagement and personalized learning experiences and accommodate diverse learning preferences and abilities. However, it is crucial to emphasize that AI should not replace human thinking but rather serve as a tool to augment and support the cognitive processes of our students. For example, AI can generate summaries of historical documents, speeches, or literary works in a history classroom, identify biases, and evaluate source reliability. Students can apply critical thinking by analyzing and assessing the output of AI systems rather than passively accepting it. This approach will deepen their understanding of historical concepts and events and develop their analytical skills.

Active Learning with AI

Recently, I spoke at the AP National Conference in Las Vegas. My session focused on sharing and explaining strategies teachers can use to engage students in the ethical and effective use of AI for learning. For example, simulating historical decision-making is an example of using AI-driven projects to help students understand complex historical events and decision-making processes, fostering deeper engagement and critical thinking. Similarly, crafting historical storytelling fosters research skill development and argumentation skills when paired with AI and augmented by analytical commentary.

Teacher Apprehension

During the conference, it became evident that attendees had varying levels of support for student use of AI in education. Many educators expressed concern about needing more training on responsibly guiding students using AI tools. A significant worry among teachers was the potential for students to rely too heavily on AI, essentially having it complete assignments for them. This apprehension extended to traditional homework assignments, with some educators questioning the validity of assigning take-home work this year. My observations reflect broader national trends. A recent survey found that only 33% of teachers believe including AI in the school curriculum is essential, and 87% report not receiving any school-based AI training. Given these concerns, it's clear that teaching methodologies need to evolve to incorporate AI into student learning ethically.

Promoting Ethical and Critical Use of AI

As educators, we are responsible for teaching students to approach AI-generated content with a discerning eye, understanding that while AI can provide valuable insights and information, it is not infallible. Encouraging critical thinking when interacting with AI tools is essential and can foster positive outcomes:

Developing digital literacy
By questioning AI outputs and assessing their limitations, students learn to navigate and evaluate digital information sources, preparing them for responsible use of technology in college and future careers.

Enhancing analytical skills
Critically examining AI-generated content for accuracy and bias helps students sharpen their analytical abilities.

Fostering creativity
When students view AI as a starting point rather than a final answer, they build upon and improve the AI output using critical and creative thinking.

Encouraging originality
Using AI as a springboard for their ideas, students produce original work reflecting their personal insights and perspectives.

Preparing for an increasingly AI-augmented future
Teaching students to work alongside AI, rather than simply relying on it, prepares them for a future where mastering human-AI collaboration will be an asset in the workplace.

AI Is Not the End Product; It Is a Stimulus

As we navigate the integration of AI in our classrooms, our goal should be to harness its potential to support and enhance student learning while maintaining the centrality of human thinking and creativity. Developing students' critical thinking, creativity, and problem-solving skills should always be the priority. By implementing thoughtful strategies and prioritizing critical thinking, we can prepare our students to thrive in a world where AI is integral to their academic and future professional lives.

AI should never be an end product in the educational process. As educators, we must integrate this tool as a dynamic stimulus to empower students in their learning journey. Interaction with AI tools should stimulate creativity, as students are prompted to think outside the box and explore innovative solutions to problems. Used appropriately, AI can be a catalyst, inspiring students to synthesize information, think critically, and produce original, thoughtful outcomes that reflect their unique perspectives and insights.

At Union Catholic, we strive to prepare our students for the ever-changing real, spiritual and virtual worlds, which means teaching them to use AI responsibly and as a tool to aid their learning. To learn more about AI at Union Catholic, please complete our Inquiry Form with any questions you have and a member of our team will be in touch!